Safe & Healthy Non Toxic Pizza Pans in 2024

Share this content

This article contains affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if a reader clicks through and makes a purchase

In the world of culinary delights, pizza holds a special place. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita, a loaded meat feast, or a vegetarian extravaganza, the perfect pizza starts with the right tools. Among those tools, the pizza pan plays a crucial role.

Most pizza pans often contain toxic materials that can leach into your food during the baking process. Which is why choosing a non toxic pizza pan is essential to eliminate the risk of harmful substances contaminating your food.

What materials are commonly used to make pizza pans?

The most common materials which are used to make pizza pans are aluminum, stainless steel, cast iron, ceramic, carbon steel, or even stone.

Which pizza pan materials are toxic?

The pizza pans materials that can leach into food and are harmful for health are aluminum, non-stick materials like polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), commonly known as Teflon, perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). So, it is better to avoid these materials.

Which pizza pan materials are non toxic and safe?

The safest pizza pan materials are carbon steel, stainless steel, stone, ceramic, and cast iron.

Safe & Healthy Non Toxic Pizza Pans

A pizza pan is a round or rectangular shallow pan specifically designed for baking pizzas. It provides a flat surface for the dough and helps distribute heat evenly for even baking.

A toxic free pizza pan promotes better health and well-being by avoiding exposure to toxins.

Let’s check some safest non toxic pizza pans.

1. Outset Cast Iron Pizza Pan | Non Toxic Pan for Pizza

Outset Cast Iron Pizza Pan
Brand Outset
Dimensions 14.25″D x 18.25″W x 2.25″H
MaterialCast Iron

Outset Cast Iron Pizza Pan is both PTFE and PFOA free. It is a versatile pan, Use it over a grill, stove, or in the oven. It can also be used as a paella pan.

The cool touch handles of the pan are super sturdy and the bottom of the pizza pan looks much like a griddle.

Just pre-heat the Outset pizza pan for a crunchy crush or put pizza on the pan to use it in the oven for a softer crush. 

2. Legend Cookware Cast iron Pizza Pan | 14″ Pizza Pan

Legend Cookware Cast iron Pizza Pan
Brand Legend Cookware
Size (Diameter)14″
MaterialCast Iron

Legend Cookware Cast iron Pizza Pan is a pre-seasoned pan and holds the temperature very well. You can use this pan to make pizzas in the oven or as griddle on all the stovetops.

The curved grab handles of the pan make it easy to hold it with fingers.

3. GoodCook Insulated Nonstick Carbon Steel Pizza Pan with Holes

Goodcook Non Toxic Pizza Pan
Brand GoodCook
Size (Diameter)15.75″
MaterialCarbon Steel

The GoodCook Carbon Steel Non stick Pizza Pan is the best pan for reheating leftover slices and baking frozen pizzas. It has a non stick coating which is both PFOA and PTFE free.

The pan fits all sizes of pizzas (small to large) and can be used in toaster oven or outdoor smoker. Its non-stick coating is very easy to clean and it doesn’t scratch or come off easily.

The maximum oven temperature of this pan is 450⁰ F and on evenly cooking every time pizza comes out with a perfect crisp to the crust.

4. CasaWare Pizza Cooking Pan (12-inch), Ceramic Pizza Pan

CasaWare Non Toxic Pizza Pan
Brand CasaWare
Size (Diameter)12″
MaterialCarbon Steel

CasaWare Pizza Cooking Pan is the perfect ceramic baking size pan for toaster or convection ovens. But it is not suitable for microwave oven. This carbon steel pan is completely Cadmium, Lead, PFOA, PTFE, and PFOS Free.

The maximum health tolerance of this pan is 450⁰ F. Only Plastic, rubber, silicone or wooden utensils are recommended to use with this non stick pizza pan.

The pan requires no seasoning but it is still better to put some oil after every use to eliminate any stickiness.

5. Bakken- Swiss Non Stick Pizza Pan, Teflon free Pizza Cooking Pan

Bakken Non Toxic Pizza Pan
Brand Bakken- Swiss
Size 14.8 inches x 13 inches x 1 inch 
MaterialCarbon Steel

Bakken- Swiss Non Stick Pizza Pan is another carbon steel material pan which has Swiss ILAG coating which is free of PFOA, PFOS, and PTFE. The pan is reusable and dishwasher safe as well as oven safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit (230 degrees Celsius).

It has silicone handles on both sides but the silicone will be very hot. So, it is recommended to use the pot holders for safety.

The best thing about it is that it has holes and the holes ensure that the crust cooks evenly on the bottom.

6. Deedro Pizza Baking Pan Pizza Tray, Stainless Steel Pizza Pan

Deedro Non Toxic Pizza Pan
Brand Deedro
Size (Diameter)11.8″
MaterialStainless Steel

Deedro Pizza Baking Pan is a Stainless steel pan which makes it completely non toxic and safest pizza pan. It is better to brush the pan with olive oil or butter to prevent any stickiness.

The pan is not going to rust easily and scratch up because it has no chemical coating on it. It is a great pan for homemade pizza and you can even freeze the pizza on it.

It is a thick pan but can’t be used in microwave oven and charcoal grill. Deedro baking pan is one of the healthiest pizza pans on the market.

7. RSVP International Stainless Steel Precision Pierced Pizza Pan, Healthy Pizza Pan

RSVP Non Toxic Pizza Pan
Brand RSVP International
Size (Diameter)11.25″
MaterialStainless Steel

RSVP International Stainless Steel Pizza pan is one of the healthiest options to cook or bake pizza in the toaster/Convection oven. It is far better than the nonstick pans which emit toxins in the ovens.

It is a unique pan with two handles on the edges. With side handles it is easy to remove from the oven. use it for both frozen pizzas and homemade pizzas and you won’t be disappointed.

8. Chicago Metallic Deep Dish 14″ Pizza Pan

Chicago Metallic Non Toxic Pizza Pan
Brand Chicago Metallic
Size (Diameter)14″
MaterialCarbon Steel

Chicago Metallic Pizza Pan is 14″ in diameter and 1.5″ deep. The pan has nonstick coating which is made of a layer of silicone. This makes it free of PTFE, PFOA, PFOS, and BPA.

Use it easily in outdoor grills or ovens without any issue at 450⁰ F. It is heavy and solidly built. The pan is pretty thick steel and the silicone coating feels slick to the touch so there will not be any sticking or cleaning issues.

9. P&P CHEF Pizza Cooking Pan, Stainless Steel Pizza Pan

P & P Chef Non Toxic Pizza Pan
Brand P&P CHEF
Size (Diameter)10″, 12″, 13.5″
MaterialStainless steel

P&P CHEF Pizza Cooking Pan is available in three different sizes and has no chemical coating on it. The pan has a sharp edge, a thick rim, and is durable enough to last for a long time.

The heat spread evenly on the pan surface and it is both oven and dishwasher safe. The stainless steel material makes it healthier and safer option than wooden trays and unhealthy coating pans.

Conclusion: Safe & Healthy Non Toxic Pizza Pans

When choosing a non toxic pizza pan, it’s essential to ensure that the specific product is labeled as non toxic, PTFE or PFOA free and made from safe materials.

By choosing any of the 9 above non toxic pizza pans, you can indulge in the joy of homemade pizza while prioritizing the health and well-being of yourself and your family members.

Both carbon steel and stainless steel pizza pan materials are good. The difference is only coating. If you don’t want any type of coating, stainless steel pan is the one. And if you want safe non stick coating carbon steel/cast iron pizza Pan is your best partner.

Our favorites pans are GoodCook Insulated Nonstick Carbon Steel Pizza Pan, Outset Cast Iron Pizza Pan, and RSVP International Stainless Steel Pizza Pan.

Share this content

Newsletter Updates

Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter